The Science of Wellbeing
Subscribe
Cover photo

A Stoic’s Thanksgiving

Riding out the disappointments of the holidays with ancient wisdom

Dr. Laurie Santos

Nov 22, 2021
12

Personally, I’m a big fan of Halloween. But I know lots of people look forward to the November and December holidays with total glee.

All that excited anticipation – the parties, the meals, the time away from work – can cause us to idealize what is in store over the coming weeks.

Now, I certainly don’t want to be a party-pooper – but there are bound to be bumps in the road. The turkey might burn. Maybe a storm cancels your flight. Your car might break down on the way to the Black Friday sales.

A lot of us let these mishaps upset us… potentially ruining the valuable time we need to recharge our batteries, enjoy the company of friends and loved ones, and live in the moment. Ruminating over setbacks can also crowd out any positive thoughts… as I know only too well.

A couple of winters ago, I was making the most of an unexpected day off. I had big plans for the holidays - a family party, tons of cookies to bake - and so I wanted to get some errands out of the way.

I was headed out to grab a few bottles of wine, when I slipped on some ice… and broke my kneecap. I was strapped into a brace and confined to my sofa for weeks. My holiday season was pretty much wrecked. And that’s when I came back to the Stoics.

I already knew vaguely about this ancient school of thought – but as I sat feeling sorry for myself, propped up by pillows reading The Stoic Challenge by Bill Irvine, I realised how much this philosophy can teach us about happiness today.

The Stoics – Greek and later Roman thinkers who lived 2,000 years ago – are sometimes portrayed as advocates of us all shutting down our emotions. In reality, they embraced the good emotions - like amusement and joy. But they also wanted to reduce the impact that negative emotions such as anger and frustration have on our happiness.

I was pretty bummed when I broke my kneecap. Aside from the pain and discomfort, I felt stupid for slipping on the ice in the first place; sad that all my fun plans were cancelled; and guilty for the impact my immobility would have on my husband, friends and family.

The Stoics would say all these emotions were a waste of my mental energy. I had to stop asking: “Why me?”

Now, you should obviously take reasonable measures to avoid mishaps (“If you never check the gas gauge in your car, you're to blame and shame on you,” says Bill), but sometimes bad things are just unavoidable. And how you react to events that are out of your control is a key lesson of the Stoics.

“You've got a very interesting choice of whether you're going to play the role of victim or play the role of target,” says Bill. “And it's a huge psychological difference.”

Imagine that somewhere the Stoic gods are hatching plans to throw obstacles in your path – breaking your stove as you put the turkey in, or burning out your fuse just when you plug in your holiday lights – how will you react?

A “victim” might get super angry (possibly ruining the holiday mood for everyone around them) or they might withdraw into self-pity and sadness.

A “target” on the other hand looks at such setbacks as a challenge to relish – like a daily crossword or Sudoku puzzle . “Targets” see problems as way to improve their coping skills and deal with challenges with good humor and a certain excitement.

I’ve personally found this Stoic way of reframing the small problems we face each and every day to be really useful. So no matter what troubles and inconveniences the Stoic gods throw at you this holiday season, I hope you too can meet them without all those negative emotions. Because - even though it’s no Halloween - this really can be a time of year to embrace and savor.

Stay well,

Laurie

I hope you're enjoying The Science of Wellbeing, my weekly newsletter looking at the latest research on happiness. If you find the tips and insights useful, please share these articles to help spread the word.

Anyone can subscribe for free here.

Subscribe for free to The Science of Wellbeing
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with Dr. Laurie Santos to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
12

More from The Science of Wellbeing
See all

Why Do I Teach the Science of Happiness?

“All rightie! Let’s get started.”
Sep 8, 2021
2
16

It Won't Hurt as Much as You Think: How we're Bad at Predicting Pain and Pleasure

All the things you are banking on to make you happy - the big house; the long vacation - won't have quite the lasting impact you think.
May 23
3
4

The Yacht Race: Why Even the Super-Rich Fall For the Myth that More Money Equals More Happiness.

If even billionaires get the blues when they compare themselves to richer peers, maybe we should challenge our belief that money always increases wellbeing.
May 16
4
9
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

12 Comments

  • Ashish Kelkar
    A great article!! Thank you, Laurie. A good sense of humour is so important to battle away odds in life. My observation is that it comes naturally to you by practising it, and one becomes resilient to the frustrating situations in life.
    • 26w
    • Author
      Dr. Laurie Santos
      Definitely. The Stoics were big on reacting to life's challenges with good humor.
      • 26w
  • Lorrie Mileham
    WOW God, I wonder how you're going to handle THIS one! - quote from a wise Christian friend
    • 26w
    • Author
      Dr. Laurie Santos
      Love it! Very stoic!
      • 26w
  • Cj Valentine
    I've got some studying to do for sure. I'm guessing I'm more of a target but almost with the expectations of the problem happening. I have the "excitement" but I'll have to look for the
    good humor.
    • 26w
  • Esteban Acosta
    Hi Laurie, you reminded me of Steve Covey, who conceptually said and wrote the same thing about it saying (or perhaps paraphrasing the aesthetics): Between the stimulus and the response there is a space (of time) and in that space resides our freedom a…
    See more
    • 26w
  • Phyllis Mikolaitis
    Great article.! Your class inspired me to use what I learned from my four battles with cancer to write a book of hints and tips to survive the challenge. It will be on Amazon in two weeks. Thanks for your wonderful class. I recommend it to everyone!
    • 26w
    • Author
      Dr. Laurie Santos
      Congrats on the new book!
      • 26w
  • Nieves Rivera
    Definitivamente nuestra forma de ver los eventos desafortunados es lo que hace la diferencia entre tener un día placentero (y así transmitirlo) o un gran terrible día y así hacérselo a los demás que nos rodean. No podemos controlar la facticidad de la …
    See more
    • 26w
  • Frida Diaz
    Definitivamente cada momento de la lectura enriquece el optimismo del día a día, especialmente en esta época del año en la que encontraremos algunos pares que no serán empáticos con el espíritu navideño. A sonreírle a la vida, con entusiasmo y alegría.
    • 26w
  • Caemin O Connor
    Great article Laurie, read a very interesting piece on this topic last year, here's the link - https://www.theguardian.com/.../how-stoics-are-speaking...
    ‘Dress rehearsal for catastrophe’: how Stoics are speaking to locked-down readers
    THEGUARDIAN.COM
    ‘Dress rehearsal for catastrophe’: how Stoics are speaking to locked-down readers
    ‘Dress rehearsal for catastrophe’: how Stoics are speaking to locked-down readers
    • 26w
    • Author
      Dr. Laurie Santos
      Great article. Thanks for sharing!
      • 26w
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in Whatsapp
Share on Linkedin
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies
© Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications